| Issue | Cover Appearance? | Comment | Reprinted In |
| Hit #32 | Yes | vs. Merlin the Wizard | |
| Plastic Man #1 | Yes | "The Camoflaging Device", "The Game of Death", "The Goon", "Go West, Plastic Man" | Flashback #11, Plastic Man Archives #2 |
| Plastic Man #2 | Yes | "The Gay Nineties Nightmare", "Is Plastic Man Crazy", "The Lava Man" - vs. The Lava Man, "Who's Who?" | Comic Reprints, Oklahoma |
| Plastic Man #3 | Yes | "The Killing of Snoopy Hawks", The Witch Doctors and the Pickle Formula", "Whaling" | (Snoopy Hawks) -Detective Comics #441 |
| Plastic Man #4 | Yes | "The Purple Viking" - vs. The Purple Viking, "King Lughead the First", "Plas' To Meet You", "The Lobster" | |
| Plastic Man #5 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #6 | Yes | "Gazelle von Vonder", "Say It Ain't So, Plas!", vs. The Moon Wizard, Mother Goose | Plastic Man #11 (1964) |
| Plastic Man #7 | Yes | vs. Dr. Volt | |
| Plastic Man #8 | Yes | vs. Eight Ball | |
| Plastic Man #9 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #10 | Yes | "Electra, Beauty of the Underworld" | |
| Plastic Man #11 | Yes | vs. Robber Barron | |
| Plastic Man #12 | Yes | vs. Riverman, Spadehead | |
| Plastic Man #13 | Yes | vs. Jets, vs. Mr. Hazard | |
| Plastic Man #14 | Yes | vs. Concrete | |
| Plastic Man #15 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #16 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #17 | Yes | "Plastic Man Products" | DC Special #15 |
| Plastic Man #18 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #19 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #20 | Yes | "Sadly-Sadly" | Jimmy Olsen #150 |
| Plastic Man #21 | Yes | "Kra Vashnu", "Where is Amorpho?" vs. Amorpho | Plastic Man #16 (1964) |
| Plastic Man #22 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #23 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #24 | Yes | vs. Reflecto | |
| Plastic Man #25 | Yes | "The Magic Cup", vs. Mr. Aqua | DC Special #15 |
| Plastic Man #26 | Yes | vs. Pike Ronan | |
| Plastic Man #27 | Yes | vs. the Leader | |
| Plastic Man #28 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #29 | Yes | vs. Tricky Toledo | |
| Plastic Man #30 | Yes | vs. Dazzla | |
| Plastic Man #31 | Yes | vs. Raka the Witch Doctor | |
| Plastic Man #32 | Yes | vs. Mr. Fission | |
| Plastic Man #33 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #34 | Yes | vs. Serena Sloop | |
| Plastic Man #35 | Yes | vs. Dr. Quomquat, the Hypnotist | |
| Plastic Man #36 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #37 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #38 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #39 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #40 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #41 | Yes | vs. The Bounding Bandit | |
| Plastic Man #42 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #43 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #44 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #45 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #46 | Yes | vs. the Spider | |
| Plastic Man #47 | Yes | vs. The Fiend | |
| Plastic Man #48 | Yes | vs. Killer Crossbones | |
| Plastic Man #49 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #50 | Yes | vs. Iron Fist | |
| Plastic Man #51 | Yes | ||
| Plastic Man #52 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #1 | Yes | "The Origin of Plastic Man" - 1st appearance and origin | The Great Comic Book Heroes (1965), Comic Reprints (Oklahoma), DC Special #15, A Smithsonian Book of Comic Book Comics, Secret Origins of the DC Super-Heroes, Plastic Man Archives #1 |
| Police Comics #2 | No | (no title) - breaks up opium smuggling operation and joins the police force of Windy City | Plastic Man Archives #1 |
| Police Comics #3 | No | (no title) - breaks up Pin Ball racket | DC Special #15, A Smithson Book of Comic Book Comics, Plastic Man Archives #1 |
| Police Comics #4 | No | (no title) - vs. Madam Brawn and her Crime School for Deliquent Girls | Plastic Man Archives #1 |
| Police Comics #5 | Yes | (no title) - vs. Madam Brawn part 2, D:Madam Brawn, marijuana reference | Plastic Man Archives #1 |
| Police Comics #6 | Yes | (no title) - vs.disembodied hands | Plastic Man Archives #1 |
| Police Comics #7 | Yes | (no title) - vs. The United Crooks of America | Plastic Man Archives #1 |
| Police Comics #8 | Yes | (no title) - vs. scientist using a giant mechanical 8-Ball | Plastic Man Archives #1 |
| Police Comics #9 | Yes | "Satan's Son Sells Out To The Japs" - vs. Hairy Arms | Plastic Man Archives #1 |
| Police Comics #10 | Yes | (no title) - vs. Axis Agents | Plastic Man Archives #1 |
| Police Comics #11 | Yes | (no title) - vs. Tad Wilkins taken over by the immortal, disembodied brain of Cyrus Smythe | Plastic Man Archives #1 |
| Police Comics #12 | Yes | (no title) - prevents corrupt swami from blackmailing actress | Plastic Man Archives #1 |
| Police Comics #13 | Yes | "The Man Who Couldn't Be Harmed" - I:Woozy Winks | Plastic Man Archives #1 |
| Police Comics #14 | Yes | (no title) - Part 2 from last issue, Woozy and Plastic Man try to capture Eel O' Brian | Batman #238, Plastic Man Archives #1 |
| Police Comics #15 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #1 | |
| Police Comics #16 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #1 | |
| Police Comics #17 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #1 | |
| Police Comics #18 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #1 | |
| Police Comics #19 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #1 | |
| Police Comics #20 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #1 | |
| Police Comics #21 | Yes | vs. Serpina | Plastic Man Archives #2 |
| Police Comics #22 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #2 | |
| Police Comics #23 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #2 | |
| Police Comics #24 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #2 | |
| Police Comics #25 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #2 | |
| Police Comics #26 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #2 | |
| Police Comics #27 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #2 | |
| Police Comics #28 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #2 | |
| Police Comics #29 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #2 | |
| Police Comics #30 | Yes | Plastic Man Archives #2 | |
| Police Comics #31 | Yes | vs. the Mangler | |
| Police Comics #32 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #33 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #34 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #35 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #36 | Yes | (no title) -captures Slick Dandy at a rest farm | |
| Police Comics #37 | Yes | (no title) - Woozy gets hoodwinked into helping a pretty woman | |
| Police Comics #38 | Yes | (no title) - crime goes on a rampage when Plas is thought dead | |
| Police Comics #39 | Yes | (no title) - Woozy becomes a target for criminals when he thought to be an heir | |
| Police Comics #40 | Yes | (no title) - solves murder at boarding home | |
| Police Comics #41 | Yes | (no title) - thwarts crook at department store | |
| Police Comics #42 | Yes | (no title) - vs. Dr. Dratt | |
| Police Comics #43 | Yes | (no title) - Plas and Woozy chase crooks across the Artic | |
| Police Comics #44 | Yes | (no title) - solves crime at old folks home | |
| Police Comics #45 | Yes | (no title) - vs. crooks disguised as Indians | |
| Police Comics #46 | Yes | (no title) - watches after the Owl, a kid with a knack for trouble | |
| Police Comics #47 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #48 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #49 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #50 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #51 | Yes | "The Granite Lady" - vs The Granite Lady | Comix: A History |
| Police Comics #52 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #53 | Yes | vs. Dr. Erudite | |
| Police Comics #54 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #55 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #56 | Yes | (no title) - runs afoul of crime when he disguises himself to help poor kid | |
| Police Comics #57 | Yes | (no ttile) - Plastic Man, Woozy and Mr. Misfit thwart Professor Maghoul | |
| Police Comics #58 | Yes | (no title) - vs. the Green Terror | |
| Police Comics #59 | Yes | (no title) - solves plague caused by Happiness Juice | |
| Police Comics #60 | Yes | (no title) - vs. Professor Spindrift | |
| Police Comics #61 | Yes | vs. Professor Sparks | |
| Police Comics #62 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #63 | Yes | vs. The Crab | |
| Police Comics #64 | Yes | (no title) - vs. Taffy Welch and Nobby Norton, crooks using a candy-making plant for a front | |
| Police Comics #65 | Yes | "The Apartment of Dr. Phobia" - captures Dr. Phobia while helping a couple find a home | |
| Police Comics #66 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #67 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #68 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #69 | Yes | vs. Stretcho | |
| Police Comics #70 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #71 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #72 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #73 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #74 | Yes | vs. Professor Dimwit | |
| Police Comics #75 | Yes | "Case of the Ancient Curse" | Jimmy Olsen #149 |
| Police Comics #76 | Yes | vs. Mr. Morbid | |
| Police Comics #77 | Yes | vs. Skullface and Eloc | |
| Police Comics #78 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #79 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #80 | Yes | vs. Gargantua, Penetro | |
| Police Comics #81 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #82 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #83 | Yes | vs. King of Crime | |
| Police Comics #84 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #85 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #86 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #87 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #88 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #89 | Yes | vs. The Vanishers | |
| Police Comics #90 | Yes | vs. Captain Rivers, pirate | |
| Police Comics #91 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #92 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #93 | Yes | vs. Dr. Ameeba | |
| Police Comics #94 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #95 | Yes | "Wanted Dead, Not Alive: Plastic Man" - vs. Captain Rivers | Plastic Man #18 (1964) |
| Police Comics #96 | Yes | vs. The Black Widow | |
| Police Comics #97 | Yes | vs. The Mime | |
| Police Comics #98 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #99 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #100 | Yes | vs. Thrilla, the Crime Queen | |
| Police Comics #101 | Yes | ||
| Police Comics #102 | Yes |